Core & Hysteresis Loss in Induction Motors: SMC Vs. Steel Lamination.

Posted by Fran Hanejko - August 13, 2021

Have you ever wished you had superpowers that could stop both hysteresis and eddy current loss in a project that demanded high magnetic performance?

Core loss in magnetic material is a measure of the heat generated within the material as a result of the alternating current. High core losses result in poor electric motor thermal efficiency.

An inefficient magnetic part can drag down an entire AC electric motor design. A little lesson about materials can show you how to minimize core and hysteresis losses in induction motors and other AC electromagnetic designs ...

Core & Hysteresis Loss in Induction Motors & Other AC Machines

Total core loss is actually the combination of two types of loss. Here's the difference between hysteresis loss and eddy current loss:

  • Hysteresis loss in a magnetic material depends upon the reversal of the magnetism
  • Eddy current loss occurs because of interaction between the conductor and the magnetic field

Both increase the heat level in a magnetic material. Electric motors + Heat = Electric motor inefficiency. (We’ll provide a much longer, more usable equation in a bit.)

Eddy current loss occurs in all AC electromagnetic devices, including:

  • Motors
  • Transformers
  • Power supplies

Stator core loss is a common complaint of AC induction electric motor designers, but one you can address more easily than you think ...

View the Engineering Hub >

Chart: Total Core Loss vs. Frequency

Let’s get more specific. Core losses in soft magnetic composite materials depend on the:

  • Material used
  • Component density
  • Heat treating

The following chart shows the total core loss of an increasingly popular soft magnetic composite (SMC) material. The chart also compares it to traditional M47 and M19 steel lamination (electrical steel) materials, both semi-processed to a 24 gauge (0.025” thick).

Core and hysteresis Loss in Induction Motors: soft magnetic composite Vs. Steel Lamination - Line Graph(Measured at an induction level of 1.5 Tesla.)

The SMC charted above is a Somaloy 700 5P, a high-performance powder metallurgy material.

This electric motor efficiency curve of sorts shows that SMC losses are lower than M47 electrical steel at frequencies above ~100 Hz. Meanwhile, SMC's losses vs. the M19 electrical steel are lower at frequencies above 400 Hz, give or take a few.

The chart clearly shows that soft magnetic composite is best at higher frequencies. It’s also apparent that SMCs are superior to M47 laminate at frequencies above 400 Hz. 

This core loss data assumes the SMCs were compacted to a density of 7.5 g/cm³. The data for the laminations was based on the core loss at 60 Hz for each of the two materials, then extrapolated using this core loss formula:

Core losses SMC materials formula A

And here's the hysteresis loss and eddy current losses formula for the SMC material: 

Hysteresis & Core Loss in Induction Motors - smc formulaHysteresis & Core Loss in Induction Motors - formula explanation

In the hands of your smartest engineer (maybe that’s you), this equation can calculate your core losses at any level of:

  • Induction
  • Frequency
  • Part thickness

In other words, you can learn how much heat (aka total core loss) you’ll generate using a soft magnetic composite at densities below 7.5 g/cm³ under any specific condition. Remember that higher resistivity generates less heat.

What About Core Loss in Lamination Assemblies?

Core and hysteresis Loss in Induction Motors: soft magnetic composite Vs. Steel Lamination - Line Graph 2

Most published data evaluates only a single sheet when discussing core losses in lamination steel.

But what happens when you stack them? In the example above, laminations start to falter at as low as 60 Hz compared with Somaloy 700 3P, a popular SMC material.

Core and hysteresis Loss in Induction Motors: soft magnetic composite Vs. Steel Lamination - stacked assemblies data(Open the chart in a new tab to expand it for readability.)

Size matters even less when it comes to soft magnetic composite assemblies.

The above data shows that a 1” motor lamination steel assembly has a DC permeability of 1,100. Compare that to past tests of single-sheet laminations, which have demonstrated a max permeability of 3,000+.

However, the same table shows that the magnetic performance of SMC isn’t affected by the compacted height of the component. That means SMCs' permeability and core losses stay about the same, while those of laminations take a sharp turn for the worse as assembly size increases.

Other Soft Magnetic Material Grades

The SMC 700 5P from the very first chart represents the optimal soft magnetic composite. As we've alluded to, there are variations of this state-of-the-art material available to cater to your performance and budgetary needs.

This table gives the values for each of the three major grades of soft magnetic composite:

Core and hysteresis Loss in Induction Motors - soft magnetic composite materials grade chart

How to Minimize Hysteresis Loss

So, how to reduce eddy current and hysteresis losses in a magnetic core? The proof is in the numbers: Soft magnetic composites go where limited laminations cannot. As a designer, it’s crucial you know the uses of soft magnetic composite compared with steel lamination:

  • Unique shape-making ability
  • Reduce number of parts per assembly
  • The efficient electric motor design capabilities proven above!

Soft magnetic composite materials are starting to outperform standard lamination materials at frequencies as low as 400. SMC even beat the popular, high-performing M19 lamination at lesser heat

Whether you're deciding how to reduce core and hysteresis losses in a transformer, a vehicle's motor, or something else, SMC is attractive for modern, high-frequency applications.

However, they are not historically ideal for induction motors used in fridges, air conditioners, etc.

That said, if you can reduce the operating cost of the product, you can spend more money on optimizing your motor. You’ll eventually save the extra money you put in on the front end.

Some pretty smart people are starting to use this concept. We hope you capitalize on the potential of soft magnetic composite, too.

ac electric motor efficiency: intro to soft magnetic composite - download e-book here!

(Editor's note: This article was originally published in September 2018 and was recently updated.)

Topics: Powdered Metallurgy, Magnetics, Materials, Applications, motors

Recent Posts

Shaping the Future: Navigating the Horizon of Powder Metallurgy's Evolution

Read More >>>

Unleashing the Potential of Sintered Soft Magnetic Materials in Modern Engineering

Read More >>>

How Advanced PM can Benefit Electric Motors

Read More >>>